Hi

Book seems to say push?

Any comments?

Table "6595472 - 5" Seat 9 is the button.
Seat 1: Player 1 (4005 in chips)
Seat 2: Player 2 (16756 in chips)
Seat 3: Player 3 (2780 in chips)
Seat 4: Player 4 (5835 in chips)
Seat 5: Player 5 sits out
Seat 8: Player 6 (7795 in chips)
Seat 9: Hero (4429 in chips)
Seat 10: Villian (8104 in chips)
Player 1: posts the ante 50
Player 2: posts the ante 50
Player 3: posts the ante 50
Player 4: posts the ante 50
Player 5: posts the ante 50
Player 6: posts the ante 50
Player 7: posts the ante 50
Hero: posts the ante 50
Villian: posts small blind 200
Player 9: posts big blind 400
----- HOLE CARDS -----
dealt to Hero [Qc 3h]
Player 1: folds
Player 2: folds
Player 3 sits back
Player 4: folds
Player 5: folds
Player 6: folds
Hero: raises to 4379 and is all-in
Villian: calls 4179
Player 9: folds
----- FLOP ----- [Qh 2h Kd]
----- TURN ----- [Qh 2h Kd][4h]
----- RIVER ----- [Qh 2h Kd 4h][Qd]
----- SHOW DOWN -----
Hero: shows [Qc 3h] (Three of a kind, Queens, King high)
Villian: shows [Kh Jh] (A Flush, King high)
Villian collected 9558 from Main pot
----- SUMMARY -----
Total pot 9558 Main pot 9558 Rake 0
Board [Qh 2h Kd 4h Qd]

i think it was a good spot to push, regardless of your cards..you just got screwed.

this is almost completely read/table dependent

if my table image and reads on the villain are optimal, I push any two cards there...but you have to use extra discretion when it's the chip leader.

it is profitable to push ATC here most of the time, nh

probably good push, but payouts, buyin, reads can be important here

For 1000 extra chips you won't be much better off. Probably a fold and wait for better cards.