polarizing the question like this is silly, versus any given opener the answer is obviously going to be in between "machine gun" and "sniper." bulletpointing the pros and cons of two extreme positions is way less helpful than actually throwing out some figures.
vs a 21/17 TAG who is mediocre/good postflop i will defend my BB from a button open with any pp, any suited ace, any offsuit AT or better, all suited broadways, a few offsuit broadways, and a smattering of other suited connectors and 1-gappers. plugged that range into pokerstove and it's around 23% of hands, which seems pretty reasonable
also your article makes no mention of the differences between SB and BB defense. (BB defense% should be a little higher and can incorporate more flatcalling than SB defense)
edit: i'm talking about NLHE btw, no idea if that's what your article is about or not, as you never mention. i'm not much of a lhe player, but i'm pretty sure BB defense vs. an LP open is supposed to be way way way higher than nlhe.
Last edited by squeezyplayer; 01-21-2009 at 11:12 PM.
|