Sure a 25nl player can squeeze but I would want some evidence first from previous hands.

This guy is far too nitty, 17/8 isn't squeezing anywhere near enough to make this profitable.

Fold.

__________________
For Free Money, Rakeback and some 6x Ongame bonuses, I recommend PokerSource.

I recommend Cardrunners for superb poker coaching. It was honestly the single biggest improvement in my game signing up there! Sign-up fee might seem steep, but it pays itself back within weeks.